Cadillac STS-V understanding test result diversity

As a part of understanding the HPTuners data I am seeing I captured these snapshots from two different 0-60 test runs:

Time 11:

Time 11:01.531

Time 16:

 

Time 16:31.875

Summary:  Same Cadillac STS-V, same day, same driver, one run later than the other run.  Different locations.

On the 2nd run the car is able to maintain a lot more timing — 26 degrees of advance vs 18.5 degrees on the first run.  The MAT temp on the 2nd run is at 145F while it hits 171F on the first — for the identical 109F IAT2!  The boost is 0.4 psi higher on the 2nd run — the boost varies pulse to pulse so that could be noise.  Lots of variables — again, 2 runs from the same car same day same gas 5 minutes apart.

These two runs resulted in very similar 0-60 mph times — 4.9 sec on the first one and 4.8 sec on the 2nd one.  This sort of rich diversity in the results certainly is intriguing; let me know if you see something obvious that I am missing on why!

Updated baseline Cadillac STS-V 0-60 time

We had a last glimpse of colder weather today so I did a new baseline for my 2008 Cadillac STS-V with Spectre cold air intake.

Low on fuel, forecast 45.6F, Baro 30.05

Lost some of the data on the PerformanceBox — the text files captured properly, but the dbn full datafile did not.  I have archived and erased the SD card in case it was an issue with file naming or similar.  Meanwhile the capture was a 0-60 time of 4.9sec, followed by the best run a 0-60mph time of 4.8s:
————— Run 0006 —————
Date 23/03/2012

Accel results
Speed(mph)     Time(s)
0-60     04.8

Accel Distance results
Distance()     Time(s)     @Speed(mph)
0-60′     02.4     32.2

Misc PkAccelG     0.68G
Equivalent data from a prior run for comparison:
————— Run 0004 —————
Date 20/08/2011

Accel results
Speed(mph)     Time(s)
0-60     05.0

Accel Distance results
Distance()     Time(s)     @Speed(mph)
0-60′     02.3     33.4

Misc
PkAccelG     0.66G

I was running the HPTuners capture at the same time on the netbook, and it showed a 0-60 time of 5.12s which is probably a ‘no rollout’ equivalent for the 4.8s run.

HP Tuners Dashboard capture

At the end of a run we can see ambient 50F, IAT1 57F, IAT2 109F, and MAT 145F but only a hint of IAT retard -0.4 degrees.

Continuing my analysis of incoming air temps over speed under different conditions:

Baseline from August 2011

MPH (Temps in Deg Fahrenheit)
Deltas Item 0 30 45 60 Deltas
Ambient 90 90 90 90 0
23 IAT1 113 117 113 106 -7
5 IAT2 118 120 127 135 17
2 MAT 120 121 136 169 49
Hot: Trimmed Trim Mar 2012
75F
Deltas MPH (Temps in Deg Fahrenheit)
Item 0 30 45 60 Deltas
Ambient 75 75 75 75 0
16 IAT1 91 93 93 91 0
33 IAT2 124 122 129 136 12
-2 MAT 122 121 134 163 41
Cold Baseline Mar 2012
75F
Deltas MPH (Temps in Deg Fahrenheit)
Item 0 30 45 60 Deltas
Ambient 50 50 50 50 0
5 IAT1 55 57 57 57 2
35 IAT2 90 90 97 104 14
1 MAT 91 90 101 132 41

Summary:

Good delta between IAT1 and ambient — the new isolation around the Spectre intake is helping keep it cooler for the stop it takes to setup a run.

IAT2 was already at 35F at the start of the run, but only gains 14F during the run.

The MAT calculated (anticipated) IAT temp increases 41F during the run, consistent with the hot run.

Here is a comparison of IAT2s from the 2 different runs today — very similar 104F at peak,

Cold Baseline Mar 2012 1st Run



Deltas MPH (Temps in Deg Fahrenheit)
Item 0 30 45 60 Deltas
Ambient 54 54 54 54 0
7 IAT1 61 63 64 64 3
23 IAT2 84 86 97 104 20
2 MAT 86 88 101 143 57
Cold Baseline Mar 2012 2nd Run



Deltas MPH (Temps in Deg Fahrenheit)
Item 0 30 45 60 Deltas
Ambient 50 50 50 50 0
5 IAT1 55 57 57 57 2
35 IAT2 90 90 97 104 14
1 MAT 91 90 101 132 41

although with different resulting MATs.

Overall, good 0-60 run of 4.8s and 4.9s and more data to consider for the air temps.  Also a good baseline before the Corsa arrives.

Cadillac Signature Styling Enhances ATS Performance

Hundreds of testing hours in wind tunnel helps reduce drag, wind noise

DETROIT — The 2013 Cadillac ATS’s all-new vehicle architecture provided Cadillac designers with the unique opportunity to tailor the compact luxury sedan’s styling and refinement cues to improve driving performance. This aspect of the ATS’s development is highlighted in the fifth chapter of a YouTube video series.

“The primary function of the ATS is to be a driver’s car, fun to drive, nimble and quick,” said Bob Boniface, Cadillac exterior design director. “It has a great powertrain, great chassis, so we wanted the exterior design to reinforce that message. We worked very closely with Engineering to ensure our design met all of the performance metrics they had set out.”

A long, 109.3-inch (2,775 mm) wheelbase and wide front/rear tracks are the cornerstones of the ATS’s firmly planted stance, which is enhanced by short overhangs and taut sheet metal that appears to wrap tightly around the tires.

Cadillac’s prominent shield grille is more agile and athletic, featuring active grille shutters that close at certain highway speeds to reduce aerodynamic drag and enhance fuel economy. The center, high mounted stop light (CHMSL) on the rear decklid provides downforce to improve aerodynamic performance.

“When you start a new program, a new architecture, it’s much different than re-skinning something else. The opportunity is both challenging and rewarding,” said Taki Karras, Cadillac ATS exterior design manager. “The ATS has a lot of gesture in the line work and that leads to the overall performance nature.”

The ATS’s clay models and full sheet metal models spent hundreds of hours in wind tunnel testing to reduce wind noise and drag, improve air flow and performance and enhance fuel economy.

A driver-focused interior with integrated technology and crafted materials complements the exterior elements and supports the ATS’s driving experience. Everything from the placement of the pedals to the position of the shifter is designed for effortless and intuitive performance driving. Available performance seats have power-adjustable bolsters to optimize lateral support during high-load cornering

“I think what will surprise people most when they get in the ATS is we’ve given them a beautiful driving environment with plenty of space in what seems like a small exterior,” said Eric Clough, Cadillac interior design director.

Contributing to the interior’s intuitive feel is an instrument panel that wraps into the doors and a center stack in the mid-instrument panel that flows into the center console. LED lighting for the bold gauge cluster enables clear, at-a-glance viewing in all lighting conditions, while ambient lighting accents functional elements of the console and doors.

“When you drive this car, its combination of design, powertrain and engineering and interior design. It’s the entire package,” Boniface said. “This isn’t just another car, it’s a Cadillac.”