Re: Cadillac killed the Electric Car (in 1912 with the electric starter)

The National Post has an interesting article Cadillac killed the electric car explaining a popular theory that the electric car originally lost out to its gasoline competitor once Cadillac developed the electric starter.  Although I like the logic of this also, by 1912 when Cadillac created the electric starter I believe that the gas powered car had already become dominant.  The electric starter was important to the continued development and enjoyment of gasoline powered cars by everyone (and SAFER!).

Charles Kettering, GM Engineer, with the first electric starter

Early cars were steam powered, or battery powered, or electric, or gas powered.  It was an open market, full of innovators and experimentation.  The reason the current conventions for the automobile developed was natural selection — survival of the fittest.  As each innovation or approach came to market, the public selected and bought the ones that were the most useful, and features of those models were copied or emulated by competitors.  Just over 100 years later we have today’s somewhat homogeneous automobiles.

If we all drove electric cars and someone suddenly developed a gasoline car today it would be viewed as a masterpiece.  The internal combustion engine gives the greatest independence, the quickest recharge, and the lightest, most efficient package of any of the technologies we know today.  The major drawbacks are emissions, which we have largely solved in modern automobiles via the catalytic converter, and the use of non-renewable fossil fuels.  Current gasoline is often E10, or 10% Ethanol; and many flex-fuel cars can run on E85, or 85% ethanol / 15% gasoline.  It is fair then to say that we can run many of today’s internal combustion engines on renewable fuels, and continue to eliminate non-renewable fossil fuels.

The reason I am so excited about extended range electric vehicles (EREV)  like the Chevrolet Volt or the Cadillac Converj Concept is that they give options.  Every vehicle can be characterized by stored energy (in the form of gasoline for conventional cars), and time of refueling (visiting a gas station, or plugging in to house current for an extended range electric vehicle).  What the EREVs give us is more options.  In my daily commute I may be able to charge at home, never need to use the gas mode, and seldom need to refuel at a gas station.  That convenience is important to me.  I am unlikely to be able to generate more gasoline at home.  There are however ways to generate electricity safely at home (solar).  Even drawing off the grid however just the convenience of a car that automatically refuels itself in my garage is an improvement.

Plug-in hybrids like the Cadillac XTS Concept have a different mix of attributes along that same range.  How much battery should a hybrid carry?  Enough to run the automobile for 10 miles or 20 miles or 40 miles?  The trade off is in weight for the battery, and oddly enough in time of recharge.  If I only commute 10 miles a day, I don’t need a 40 mile battery.  GM’s two-mode Hybrids today such as in the Escalade Hybrid tend to be able to travel in electric-only mode only at slow speeds and for only a very short range.  The plug-in hybrids (designed to plug in to wall current and recharge overnight) will have an extended battery reserve, and an extended range.  In question is how far that extended range should be.  The first full EREVs will have a 40 mile range and so a LOT of battery power and weight.  I am hopeful the plug in hybrids will have a 20 mile range, which would give me a lot of options in my commute.

This is a terrific time for the automobile.  We have higher performance vehicles than ever before, cleaner vehicles than ever before, and safer vehicles than ever before.  The new vehicles are promising to be even better than the ones we drive today.  I am very optimistic that Cadillac is bringing automobiles to market that will continue to provide enjoyment for automobile lovers.

Cadillac 6-Speed Automatic (6L50)

The current Cadillac CTS and STS both use a 6-Speed Automatic Transmission designated 6L50 by GM.  The RWD and AWD variants of each car all use the same versatile automatic transmission.  In the case of the STS, both the V6 and the Northstar V8 use this transmission.  The CTS-V uses the beefed up for the power 6L90 variant.

2010 Hydra-Matic 6L50 Transmission: Type: six speed RWD / AWD, electronically controlled automatic overdrive transmission with torque converter clutch. Clutch-to-clutch architecture, with integral Electro / Hydraulic Controls Module.

Only the Cadillac DTS continues with the 4L80e 4-Speed Automatic.  The addition of a 6-speed automatic in the CTS and STS allows for more responsive acceleration at a variety of speeds while still having good gearing for highway touring.  Cadillac and GM Power train continue to design tremendous flexibility into their key components.  When a single well-engineered, proven component such as the 6-Speed Auto 6L50 can be used in multiple configurations and multiple installations everyone benefits.

In the GM transmission naming scheme, 6 is for 6-speed, L is for longitudinally mounted (versus transverse as in FWD cars), and 50 indicates a mid-range torque capability.  Mid-range is relative, as this transmission’s power ranges exceed the top-end of the previous generation.  However, the V-Series and Corvette engines have established new definitions for high-torque.

The 6L50 is a ‘smart’ transmission.  It uses Enhanced Performance Algorithm Shifting to react appropriately for the dynamics of the situation the Cadillac is executing — holding gears through corners to avoid the disruption of a shift and torque transition.  It also allows driver gear selection similar to an automated manual transmission, but at no time does it lose the aplomb one expects of a luxury performance automobile.


Maximum engine power: 315 bhp ( 235 kw )
Maximum engine torque: 332 lb-ft ( 450 Nm )
Maximum gearbox torque: 480 lb-ft ( 651Nm )
Gear ratios: MYB
First: 4.06
Second: 2.37
Third: 1.55
Fourth: 1.16
Fifth: 0.85
Sixth: 0.67
Reverse: -3.2
Maximum shift speed 7000 rpm
Maximum Validated Weights: ( Target ) GVW: 6613 lb ( 3000 kg ), GCVW: 12505 lb ( 5672kg )
7-position quadrant: P, R, N, D, X, X, X ( X = available calibratable range position )
Case description: 3-piece ( Bell, main, extension )
Case material: die cast aluminum
Shift pattern: (2) Three-way on/off solenoids
Shift quality: Five variable bleed solenoid
Torque converter clutch: Variable Bleed Solenoid ECCC
Converter size: 240, 258mm ( reference )
Fluid type: DEXRON® VI
Fluid capacity: w/258mm converter 9.1 kg
Transmission weight: w/258mm converter wet: 85-90 kg ( 187-198 lb ) estimated
Pressure taps available: line pressure
Assembly sites: GMPT Strasbourg, France
GMPT Ypsilanti, MI
GMPT Silao, MX
Applications: Cadillac STS
Cadillac CTS
Cadillac CTS Wagon
Chevrolet Camaro
Buick Park Ave (China)
Available Control Features: Multiple Shift Patterns ( Selectable )
Driver Shift Control ( Tap Up / Tap Down )
Enhanced Performance Algorithm Shifting ( PAS )
Selectable Tow / Haul Mode
Engine Torque Management On All Shifts
Altitude and Temperature Compensation
Adaptive Shift Time
Neutral Idle
Reverse Lockout
Automatic Grade Braking
Additional Features: OBDII / EOBD
Integral Electro/Hydraulic Controls Module ( Tehcm )
Control Interface Protocol – GMLAN

2010 Hydra-Matic 6L50 (MYB)
Hydra-Matic 6L50 six-speed automatic RWD / AWD Car & Truck transmission

2010 Model Year Summary

Cadillac CTS and CTS Sport Wagon are new applications for 2010.

Modular Design for Application Flexibility

The major focus of activities for the 2010 will be quality improvements.

Modular design for application flexibility

The 6L50 was designed to accept different engines and different mounting locations, as well as the ability to mate to transfer cases for all-wheel-drive capability. For 2010, the applications are Cadillac CTS and CTS Wagon, STS, and Chevrolet Camaro. It is derived from the similar 6L80 rear- and all-wheel-drive capable six-speed automatic transmission available in the Chevrolet Corvette, Chevrolet Camaro, as well as Chevrolet, Cadillac, and GMC full-size SUVs.

Overview

The Hydra-Matic 6L50 six-speed automatic transmission for rear- and all-wheel-drive cars is designed with the same modular flexibility as the larger 6L80, as well as being fully compatible with advanced electronic controls. Its unique output gearset configuration enables it to have a wider range of ratios than a conventional planetary gearset automatic transmission.

The main housing for both the Northstar V8 and High Feature V6 in the CTS, STS sedans and the SRX crossover vehicle is identical. The modular concept of the new Hydra-Matic 6L50 centers on the desire for common components and manufacturing tooling for four different size variants of the new 6-speed family. Like the larger 6L80, the 6L50 uses three gearsets, a simple input planetary gearset, and two output gearsets, one of which is a compound gearset with three pairs of two pinion gears on the output carrier, one pair meshing with the sun gear and the other with the ring gear. This arrangement allows for optimal ratio steps with a 6.04:1 overall spread.

All applications feature adaptive shift controls. Several additional features such as grade braking, Performance Algorithm Shifting, and Driver Shift Control are available on some of the applications. Performance Algorithm Shifting (PAS), which detects when the vehicles are being driven in a spirited fashion and remains in its current gear ratio even when the driver lifts a foot off the accelerator pedal. PAS monitors how assertively the driver is using engine output to determine at what engine speed to upshift of downshift. Driver Shift Control, available in the STS and SRX, allows the driver to shift the transmission like a clutchless manual gearbox. Electronic safeguards prevent over-revving should the wrong gear position be accidentally selected.

The wide overall ratio spread of 6.04:1 allows a “steep” first gear, as well as very “tall” overdrive top gear for low-rpm highway cruising. Acceleration is maximized, as is fuel economy. Engine noise is also lower during cruising. Both fifth and sixth gears are “overdrive” gears, for example.

Gear changes from second to sixth gear ratios are accomplished with clutch-to-clutch action, where an “oncoming” clutch is engaged and an “offgoing” clutch is released in a precise manner to achieve the ratio change. The first-to-second upshift, however, is a freewheeling action, where the second gear clutch engages while the first gear one-way clutch spins freely. This allows a greater degree of smoothness at lower vehicle speeds. The manner in which each gear is selected in the 6L50 is optimized for best performance.

Advances in transmission control modules allow the modules to exist reliably inside the transmission, where temperatures remain fairly constant compared to a body-mounted module. The transmission and module are assembled together, so no additional steps are necessary during vehicle assembly.

The 32-bit transmission control module (TCM) monitors transmission performance and compensates for normal wear in components such as clutch plates, so transmission performance remains consistent for the life of the transmission. The control module also “tests” the components of the transmission following assembly to optimize the interaction of the components. The module strategy, developed by GM, is compatible with future global applications.

The CTS and STS V6 use a 258mm diameter torque converter which features a lockup clutch, which also makes use of GM’s proprietary electronic controlled capacity clutch (ECCC) technology. ECCC uses a small, regulated amount of slip to dampen out engine pulses. This creates a smoother running drivetrain, especially during shift events.

The 6L50 all-wheel-drive transfer case in the Cadillac CTS application uses an active center differential, responding to traction conditions and assigning torque to the axle with most available traction.

Low maintenance

The 6L50 uses DEXRON VI premium fluid, which is validated to improve durability and shift stability over the life of the transmission. DEXRON VI, was developed to have a more consistent viscosity profile; a more consistent shift performance in extreme conditions; and less degradation over time. Internal GM tests have demonstrated DEXRON VI delivers more than twice the durability and stability in friction tests compared to existing fluids. The DEXRON VI fluid was designed specifically and validated for the new family of GM six-speed automatic transmissions.

The Hydra-Matic 6L50 is produced in Ypsilanti, Michigan, Strasbourg, France, and Silao, Mexico.

Adding Style to the new CaddyInfo Forum

One of the special features of our new CaddyInfo Cadillac Forum re-styling is that each Reader can pick their own header and footer imagery while reading the forum.
The animation gif below shows the forum sequencing through the 3 choices (unfortunately backwards from 3 to 1 but you can get the idea).

Only the header image is show for brevity; check out the CaddyInfo Cadillac Forum for the live version.

By selecting from Style 1 or Style 2 or newly added Style 3, the Reader can select from 3 sets of Header/Footer image combinations. All of them are Cadillacs of course, as this is CaddyInfo after all.

  • Style 1 has the XTS at the top and CTS Sport Wagon at the bottom.
  • Style 2 has a CTS at the top and Escalade at the bottom.
  • Style 3 has a 2003 DTS top and bottom a CTS-VR 1st Gen Racing Car at the bottom.

I added Style 3 today, and hope to have one or two more styles available so we have something that suits most any of our Readers.

I would also like to thank Sweetie of Shessothere.com for the unsolicited suggestion to rename this blog to “Cadillac Conversations”.

Also a big thanks for the rapid development of the new CaddyInfo Forum Skin by:

2ipb: Caddyinfo.com by =the-danzor on deviantART