How Exclusive Should Cadillac be?

In 2004 Cadillac had achieved a new beginning.  The new CTS, SRX, and STS were being produced in the new Cadillac factory at Lansing Grand River, and the DTS came out of the 90s Cadillac home in Hamtramck.  The XLR was produced in the Corvette factory at Bowling Green, on a separate Cadillac assembly line.  Sure the Escalades were coming from the huge truck factories at Arlington and Ramos, but Cadillac almost had retrieved some actuality of independence and uniqueness within General Motors.

Today the CTS, CTS-V, CTS Sport Wagon, and CTS Coupe all are made at Lansing Grand River (LGR).  The STS, taking its final bow for 2011 is also a LGR product.  The new SRX comes from Ramos, and the Escalade production has all shifted to Arlington, Texas.  The new XTS replacement for the DTS is headed for Oshawa, Ontario to be built in the state of the art flexible manufacturing facility.  The production home of the ATS to my knowledge has not been announced.  So all in all Cadillac’s home continues to be the LGR facility, although their best sellers come from Arlington or Ramos, and soon (hopefully) from Oshawa.

Targeting a single-factory home like LGR would make Cadillac more like an independent Automobile Marque.  It would also mean limiting total production that Cadillac would be capable of.  Should General Motors target a certain level of production in order to ensure exclusivity for Cadillac?  Or should GM continue to produce and sell as many Cadillacs as the Public can consume?  Limiting production would have the advantage of driving up residual values for leases, and it would tend to drive up the average retail transaction price for Cadillac Dealers.  The obvious downside is fewer sales and less overall profit opportunity.  If Cadillac is to compete on the world stage with BMW and Mercedes, they need to get sales back to 200K / year or even the days of 300K / year of Cadillacs rolling out of the factories.  The upcoming ATS Family alone, if it is to compete with the BMW 3-Series, will need to sell around 100K examples.

I for one am confident that the current Cadillac team has the right feel for what makes a Cadillac uniquely a Cadillac.  It does not matter to me which factory Cadillacs come from, as long as when they arrive they are proudly and fiercely Cadillacs — luxury and performance automobiles built to a standard of excellence without compromise.

2011 is a bit of a transition model year for Cadillac.  Early retirement of the DTS, retirement of the XLR without replacement, and the fading STS sales may make calendar 2010 and calendar year 2011 sales a recent low point in overall Cadillac production. Upcoming arrival of the new ATS and XTS in 2012 or 2013 should drive a rapid blooming of Cadillac sales.  Hopefully with the CTS Coupe arrival the Dealer network can prosper though the fallow time until the new models arrive.

2011 Changes at Cadillac

The new Order Books are here!  The new Order Books are here!

The GM Dealer Order Books now have the 2011 Models added.  Here are the major changes:

DTS:  Retired (!)

So far the DTS does not appear in the 2011 Order Book.

STS: V8 Retired, New Colors

Deletions
V8 Model 6DC29
Exterior color (GBO) Blue Diamond Tricoat
Exterior color (GIP) Black Cherry
(K59) Adaptive Cruise Control
(PDU) V8 Premium Luxury Collection
(PDV) V8 Performance Luxury Collection
(Q9Y) 18″ x 8″ polished cast aluminum wheels
(F55) Continuously Variable Real Time Damping
(LH2) Northstar 4.6L VVT SFI V8 Engine
(JL7) Enhanced 4-channel StabiliTrak with Active Steering
(FE3) 4-wheel independent suspension with Magnetic Ride Control
New Features
Exterior color (GAR) Black Ice. Available at extra charge.
Exterior color (GGU) Evolution Green Metallic. Available at extra charge.

Cadillac CTS Sedan: Add 2 Colors, Delete 2 Colors, Rear View Camera added to Lux 1

Deletions
Exterior color (GBO) Blue Diamond Tricoat
Exterior color (GIP) Black Cherry
New Features
Exterior color (GAR) Black Ice Metallic. Available at extra charge.
Exterior color (GGU) Evolution Green Metallic. Available at extra charge.
(UVC) Rearview camera now part of (Y40) Level One Luxury Package.

Looks like they forgot to add the new availability of the Recaro seats on the non-V CTS.

CTS Coupe , CTS-V Coupe Premiere

New Features
CTS Coupe (Model 6DP47 and 6DH47) CTS-V Coupe (Model 6DN47)
Exterior color (GAR) Black Ice Metallic. Available at extra charge. Not available on CTS-V.
Exterior color (GGU) Evolution Green Metallic. Available at extra charge. Not available with interior (AFK) Ebony with Saffron seat inserts.
New interior color (AFK) Ebony seats with Saffron sueded fabric inserts. Available on CTS-V Coupe only. Not available with exterior color (GGU) Evolution Green Metallic.
(UVC) Rearview camera now part of (Y40) Level One Luxury Package.
(CBF) Power sunroof, single glass pane/tilt only on Coupe.
(QIV) P245/45ZR19 Y-rated summer performance tires. Included and only available in (Y43) 19″ Summer Tire Performance Package. Coupe only.
(QYO) P235/50R18 V-rated all-season blackwall tires. Coupe only.
(P86) 18″ x 8″ premium multi-coat painted finish wheels. Coupe only.
(P87) 19″ x 8.5″ polished wheels. Included and only available in (Y43) 19″ Summer Tire Performance Package. Coupe only.
(P88) 19″ x 9″ front and 19″ x 9.5″ rear, high polished wheels. Available on CTS Coupe-V.
(P89) 19″ x 9″ front and 19″ x 10″ rear, premium multi-coat painted finish wheels. Standard on CTS Coupe-V.

Saffron interior only available on the Coupe.

Cadillac CTS Sport Wagon: Add 2 colors, Delete 2 colors, Rearview Camera added to Lux 1

Deletions
Exterior color (GBO) Blue Diamond Tricoat
Exterior color (GIP) Black Cherry
New Features
Exterior color (GAR) Black Ice Metallic. Available at extra charge.
Exterior color (GGU) Evolution Green Metallic. Available at extra charge.
(UVC) Rearview camera now part of (Y40) Level One Luxury Package.

Cadillac CTS Sedan — What do you get for the money?

There are a variety of options and features that can be ordered on the Cadillac CTS.  However, there are the main branches for 2010 models for the CTS Sedan:

  • 3.0L CTS Sedan

    • Base RWD $35K or AWD $38K
    • Luxury RWD $38K or AWD $41K
    • Performance RWD $40K or AWD $42K
  • 3.6L CTS Sedan

    • Performance RWD $42K or AWD $43K
    • Premium RWD $47K or AWD $49K

Gone are the heady days of 2003-2004 when one could buy the base model CTS for under $30K! So what do you get for the money today?

For simplicity the numbers to follow focus only on the rear wheel drive models:

3.0L CTS Sedan $35K:

  • 270 hp 3.0L V6 VVT engine
  • StabiliTrak electronic stability control system
  • Premium steering
  • Bose Sound System
  • Luxury Model at $38K adds:
    • Wood trim
    • Bluetooth for phone interface
    • Interior Ambient Lighting
  • Performance Model at $40K adds:
    • 18″ aluminum wheels with premium multi-coat painted finish
    • Sport performance suspension system
    • Adaptive Forward Lighting

3.6L Performance Model for $42K includes:

  • 304 hp 3.6L V6 VVT engine
  • 18″ aluminum wheels with premium multi-coat painted finish
  • Sport performance suspension system
  • Adaptive Forward Lighting

3.6L Premium Model for $47K includes:

  • 304 hp 3.6L V6 VVT engine
  • Pop-up Navigation
  • UltraView Sunroof
  • Keyless Access/Smart Remote Start

Fuel Economy – Constant

The base 3.0L V6 and the 3.6L V6 both are rated for the same fuel economy: 18 mpg city and 27 mpg highway.  So there is no advantage other than cost savings to selecting the 3L over the 3.6L V6.

I want the sport suspension but…

I could not see getting the Sport Suspension and Performance option without also getting the 3.6L engine.  However, selecting the 3.6L Performance package is a sharp $7K option above the base price for the 3L V6.  This seems a large price of entry for a performance oriented CTS.
Interesting to note that the sportiest CTS Sedan suspension offered is now the FE2.  Previously CTS offered FE1, FE2 on the lux, and FE3 on the Sport model.   There was some feeling from reviewers that FE2 was nearly as good as FE3 on the track and much better on the street, so perhaps Cadillac made a smart selection here.

If price is no object

Is there a compelling case for the Premium CTS 3.6L over the Performance CTS 3.6L?  The Performance Model costs $42K, and the Premium model $47K.

For the extra $5K one would get standard on the Premium CTS Sedan (highlights):

  • Interior ambient mood lighting
  • Wood Trim
  • Audio system with Navigation
  • Ultrasonic rear parking
  • Heated, Ventilated seats
  • Ultraview Sunroof
  • Keyless Access / Smart remote start

The Performance model gets summer tires; the Premium model gets all-season tires.  The All-season tires give up a bit of dry grip but handle weather better.

All of these seem worthwhile for a fully optioned CTS, so if I were going $42K for the CTS Performance I would probably look for a way to move up to the $47K CTS Premium.

You have to pay to play…

The base 3L CTS at $35K includes Automatic Transmission, Stabilitrak and Bose sound, which the base Generation 1 CTS back in 2003/2004 did not.  The 3L engine at 270 hp is slightly more powerful than the non-Di 3.6L engine of 2004-2007, which put out 255 hp.
With these premium features the price has increased.  The range of price across the CTS range goes up quickly however, from the base $32K to the high-flying $47K premium package.    Maximum full featured price on a CTS can break $52K with selection of a few options.
Is the CTS even with Premium option and extra selections a good value at $52K?

Making room for the ATS

Cadillac needs pricing room below the CTS for the upcoming smaller-than-a-CTS model, the ATS.  With the arrival of the ATS, I would certainly make the CTS Sedan DI 3.6L only, and let the ATS have exclusive domain over the 3L V6.  I would price the ATS at $25-35K, and the CTS V6 at $35K-$40K.  i would introduce a CTS V8 with a 6.2L LS3 engine and 425 hp starting at $45K.  Finally, I would price the CTS-V at $60K even (currently $62K).

So my unsolicited recommendations for a CTS Sedan refresh for 2011 are:

  • 3.0L CTS Sedan – I would eliminate the 3.0L in the 2011 CTS

  • 3.6L 304 hp CTS V6 Sedan:

    • Performance RWD $35K
    • Premium RWD $40K
  • 6.2L 425 hp CTS V8 Sedan

    • Performance RWD $45K
  • Supercharged 6.2L 556 hp CTS-V

    • Performance RWD $60K

This would put the CTS in the right value ranges so that any CTS one buys is a terrific value for the money.